Realty Assets Management Singapore - Singapore Property, Assets and Real Estate Consultant - Property for Sale, Rental and Investment - Apartment, Condo, Residential, Comercial, Huttons. - Realty Assets Management

A landmark decision in a case with worldwide implications for the hospitality industry as to how hotel management agreements are interpreted and enforced in future was handed down last month by a US court. It awarded in excess of US$10 million in damages in a decision favouring the Jakarta-based Indonesian owners of The Ritz-Carlton Bali against The Ritz-Carlton Hotel Company (Ritz-Carlton), owned by Marriott International.

American law firm Bickel and Brewer announced that its client, Karang Mas Sejahtera (KMS), owner of The Ritz-Carlton Bali Resort and Spa (The Ritz-Carlton Bali), had won its case against Ritz-Carlton for violating its fiduciary duties to The Ritz-Carlton Bali.

The case revolved around the development and opening of the Bulgari Bali Hotel, which opened in September 2006 just three miles from The Ritz-Carlton Bali property. KMS successfully claimed that Ritz-Carlton had violated its agreement with KMS by operating a competing property in disregard of KMS’s territorial rights and failing to recognise its responsibilities as an agent of the Ritz-Carlton Bali.

The Bulgari Bali, which is managed by Ritz-Carlton, is the first resort in the new Bulgari Hotels and Resorts chain, a joint venture between high-fashion Italian jeweller Bulgari SpA and Marriott International, which includes such brands as J.W. Marriott, Ritz-Carlton, Renaissance and Courtyard.

Territorial exclusivity
The Bulgari Bali, only the Italian brand’s second hospitality property following its flagship hotel in Milan, opened under Ritz-Carlton management despite objections from KMS that the luxury hotel would violate the territorial exclusivity provision KMS held with Ritz-Carlton.

Among several other claims, KMS alleged that the Bulgari property was benefiting from the use of the Ritz-Carlton brand name in its marketing and promotion, in direct contravention of the operating agreement between the KMS and Ritz-Carlton.
  
On January 25, following a three-week trial, a nine-person jury in the US District Court in Greenbelt, Maryland, reached a unanimous decision that Ritz-Carlton violated its fiduciary duties to KMS and The Ritz-Carlton Bali.

The jury awarded KMS US$382,000 in actual damages and US$10 million in punitive damages, US$5 million more than KMS had requested. Filed more than three years ago, the lawsuit had become one of the industry’s most high-profile disputes between a hotel management company and individual hotel owner.

“This case is of vital importance to the hospitality industry, as it clarifies the rights, responsibilities and obligations of all parties involved in a hotel management agreement,” said William Brewer, counsel for KMS. The owners had yet to decide, as of mid-February, if they will end their relationship with Ritz-Carlton.

KMS attorneys announced: “We’ll ask the judge to restrain those ongoing breaches of loyalty by Ritz-Carlton and make sure they don’t continue.”

The jury found Ritz-Carlton was bound by contractual obligation not to use the Ritz-Carlton name and brand to operate another hotel on the Indonesian Island of Bali without the consent of KMS. Unless overturned on appeal, this jury verdict may be a seminal moment for the hospitality industry according to legal experts.

“This jury verdict compels the industry to look more closely at management agreements and evaluate the manner in which they are interpreted by all involved parties,” said James Renard, partner at Bickel and Brewer.

Privileges abused
KMS lawyers stated Ritz-Carlton continuously lied about the nature of the involvement of Ritz-Carlton employees, standards and assets in the building of a competitive brand next door. The complaint charged the hotel operators with using names, assets and resources in opening and operating the Bulgari property.

It was also alleged that Ritz Carlton abused its privileges as operator of the KMS hotel, using confidential and proprietary information owned by KMS to plan and develop the competing Bulgari hotel while concealing these purposes from KMS.

KMS successfully argued that the Bulgari Bali unfairly benefited from Ritz-Carlton’s name in marketing and promotion when it opened its 59-villa luxury hotel, just 5km up the beach from their property, revealed a report from the Wall Street Journal,

The Ritz-Carlton Bali is located on 173 acres in the Jimbaran area on the western edge of Bali’s Bukit peninsula. The resort features 368 guest rooms, including 38 new cliff villas with views overlooking the ocean, along with 12 restaurants and lounges, a golf course, tennis courts, indoor and outdoor pools, a spa and access to the secluded Kubu Beach.

The Bulgari Bali property was developed and is owned by MRA Group and Partners, the Indonesian owner of the franchised Bulgari stores in Indonesia. MRA’s other interests include luxury automobile dealerships, media and premium brand retailing. Located on the southern tip of the Bukit Peninsula above cliffs dropping straight to the sea, the resort features 59 villas overlooking the Indian Ocean, two restaurants, a spa and a private beach.